Shannon's Studio - Shannon Christensen
  • Home
    • Welcome
  • Roadmap Stops
    • 1 LIFESTYLE Landmark >
      • My Fabric Collections
    • 2 LEARNING Landmark
    • 3 LIVING Landmark >
      • 8CPH Courses
      • JUMPSTART 8 CPH
      • #1 CPH IDEABOOK
      • #2 CPH THINK TANK
      • #3 CPH SKETCHBOOK
      • #5 CPH X•X•O
      • #6 CPH SUPERPOWERS
      • #7 CPH VISION
      • #8 CPH SHOW & SHARE
    • 4 LOVING IT Landmark >
      • Illustrated Lifebook
    • 5 LEADING Landmark >
      • Build Your Body of Work • Shortcut to Your Signature Style
  • PASSPORT
  • Shop
    • Shop • 1 Lifestyle & Space
    • Shop • 2 Learning & Skills
    • Shop • 3 Living & Habits
    • Shop • 4 Loving It & Identity
    • Shop • 5 Leading & Business
    • Shop • Kids Classes
  • MORE
    • Portfolio
    • Blog - Creative Roadtrip
    • Benefits of Creativity
    • Thank you for your Purchase

Opinion • Santa, Symbols, & Schools

12/4/2011

2 Comments

 
Well, yesterday I talked about gift giving. Today I have something else on my mind. This morning I read an article about a NYC public school teacher who told her class of second graders, during a geography lesson, that there was no Santa. She was discussing the North Pole and the  children assured the teacher they knew where the it was because Santa lived there. The teacher decided to clarify that myth and said that there was no Santa. Also, she felt a need to tell them that it was their parents who put presents under the tree for them, not Santa. What exactly that had to do with geography I don't know.

After the article, there ensued a back and forth in the comments section about whether kids should be told the truth, if they should even be told to believe in Santa at all, and every opinion in between. I have issues with Santa myself. I've never told my kids there was and never told them there wasn't. When they asked me I would always respond with, "What do you think?" Sometimes they'd say what they thought and sometimes they didn't. I let them talk. So, the belief in the man Santa has been perpetuated very little, if at all, in our home. But, the spirit of Santa and Christmas has.

As an artist I'm very aware of symbols and their use.
We use symbols in society all the time. Santa Claus is a symbol. A collective symbol of the intangible attributes of joy, wonder, mystery and surprise that we have few other means to share and pass on.  For most of society we have mutually agreed to do that. Just as we've nationally decided that the American Flag is a symbol of patriotism, wedding rings a symbol of fidelity and love, and yellow ribbons a welcoming back home. Whether we choose to embrace these icons and the ideas they represent are personal choices.
Picture
Using a cut open apple as a symbol for getting to the core of the issue. Opening up to see what's really inside.
A lot of times people get so emotional that they miss the mark about what the problem is. The real issue with this situation is that this teacher believed, and acted on the idea, that it was her RIGHT to tell these children. She decided that Teacher usurps Parent. Put another way, Teacher displaces, supplants, confiscates, or cuts out Parent. This is a  policy that is being perpetuated in some schools - teacher has more right than a parent to decide - on many issues like gender, sex, and religion. The problem with not seeing the core issue is that Parent then relinquishes, surrenders ands hands over their right to Teacher.
Picture
Dominoes are used to show the effect one action has on others & why some things are worth taking a stand on.
This teacher decided in that moment, without care, concern, nor consensus of others, that she would take on the role of Parent. In her "truth-telling" did she really have regard about how the truth was told? How the children might respond to it? That it might shatter their (not her) belief system? Is this truth age appropriate? Did she let parents know that she would be busting this tradition so that they could be prepared for the aftermath? Did she let the parents know after the fact with a note home? Did she teach about symbols in society? Did she teach about the different methods of gift giving? Did she teach about celebrations? Did she teach any historical context? These are things a real parent are concerned with. That differentiates Teacher and Parent. This teacher didn't care enough about the children, nor was she willing to take on the real role of parent, to consider the outcome and welfare for those children. I for one want to be a real parent, not some make-believe one that this teacher is trying to be.

2 Comments
Chels
12/4/2011 04:32:21 am

So well said! I agree and I too have issues with Santa. I do believe in what he symbolizes and think we all have a need to believe in that good. I LOVE your paintings and their symbolism. Thanks so much for sharing. It's nice to see in words, how I feel. I can't always put into words what I think or believe, so it's nice when someone does that for you. And, yes, I too want to be a real parent!

Reply
Shannon link
12/5/2011 08:32:28 am

Chels, thanks. It is hard to articulate our thoughts and feelings so I'm glad this made sense to you. BTW, you are a real parent, a real good one.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    February 2011
    December 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010

    Pin It

    Categories

    All
    Activity
    Appreciation
    Art
    Art & Books
    Articles
    Bitesized Organized
    Biz
    Branding
    Chores
    D I Y
    Downloads
    Exhibitions
    Family
    Frame Art
    Gifts
    Graphic
    How To
    Kids
    Marriage
    Moments
    Morals
    Opinion
    Paintings
    Parenting
    Parent Traps™
    Parties
    Photos
    Policy
    Project
    Projects
    Quick Tips
    Ring Thing
    Shortcuts
    Social Media
    Teens
    Thoughts
    Tips
    Trips
    Values
    Wedding
    Women
    Work
    Youth
    Yw

    RSS Feed

Shop • 1 Creative Lifestyle & Space
Shop • 2 Creative Learning & Skills
Shop • 3 
Creative Living & Habits
Shop • 4 
Creative Loving It & Identity
Shop • 5 
Creative Leading & Business
Shop Backpacks & Bags
Shop Etsy Shannon's Studio 
2005 - 2025 © Shannon Christensen • [email protected]
  • Home
    • Welcome
  • Roadmap Stops
    • 1 LIFESTYLE Landmark >
      • My Fabric Collections
    • 2 LEARNING Landmark
    • 3 LIVING Landmark >
      • 8CPH Courses
      • JUMPSTART 8 CPH
      • #1 CPH IDEABOOK
      • #2 CPH THINK TANK
      • #3 CPH SKETCHBOOK
      • #5 CPH X•X•O
      • #6 CPH SUPERPOWERS
      • #7 CPH VISION
      • #8 CPH SHOW & SHARE
    • 4 LOVING IT Landmark >
      • Illustrated Lifebook
    • 5 LEADING Landmark >
      • Build Your Body of Work • Shortcut to Your Signature Style
  • PASSPORT
  • Shop
    • Shop • 1 Lifestyle & Space
    • Shop • 2 Learning & Skills
    • Shop • 3 Living & Habits
    • Shop • 4 Loving It & Identity
    • Shop • 5 Leading & Business
    • Shop • Kids Classes
  • MORE
    • Portfolio
    • Blog - Creative Roadtrip
    • Benefits of Creativity
    • Thank you for your Purchase